Home Contact Us
Technical Knowledge

Pigment-Settling Tests: Read the Model Before Comparing the Additive

Read two pigment-settling studies without mixing model recipes, active dosage, rheology results or storage-photo limits. A practical guide for coating trials.

Published on · Published by MOSINTER GROUP Editorial Team · About 8 min read
Original paper-cut concept illustration of white pigment particles and an ochre fiber network; not microscopy or actual test data.
On this page

A supplier's settling photograph is useful evidence about a particular dispersion. It is not a shelf-life specification for every paint containing the same rheology additive. Before choosing a trial, identify which formulation produced the result, what the additive percentage means and what was actually observed after storage.

Two Borregaard articles published in July and October 2019 make a useful case study. Both concern microfibrillated cellulose, or MFC, in titanium-dioxide dispersions. They describe separate model experiments. Keeping them separate changes how a formulator should interpret the comparison and design the next step. This is an independent reading of public supplier studies, not a MOS test, an endorsement of a grade or a claim that a material is available from MOS.

Cover: original AI-generated conceptual illustration, not microscopy, a sample photograph or a supplier test result.

Start with the experimental question

The July article compares MFC with an unnamed commercial modified-polyurea additive in a disclosed pigment-dispersion formula. The October article examines different active MFC concentrations against a reference in a separately described dispersion, alongside observations after storage. These are different questions: comparison of two additive technologies in one model, and response to MFC concentration and ageing in another.

Do not treat a shared pigment trade name as proof that two mixtures are identical. Pigment loading, liquid composition, additive delivery form and preparation can all be part of the experimental difference. A comparison table assembled from separate publications should retain a source column rather than silently presenting all results as one experiment.

July and October supplier studies: retain each model and observation scope
Evidence itemJuly 2019 studyOctober 2019 study
Disclosed pigment basis420 g pigment in a 600 g total formula: calculated 70% by massA separately described 60% pigment dispersion
Main comparisonMFC, modified polyurea and a referenceMFC concentration series and a reference
Active-additive basisThe reported comparison uses about 0.5% active additiveThe reported series includes 0.05%, 0.25% and 0.5% active MFC
Storage evidence to keep with its sourceDo not import the later publication's photographsPhotographs of the reference and 0.5% active MFC samples at 24 hours, 7 days and 28 days

The arithmetic in the first row is a calculation from the July formula, not an additional measured result. Neither publication establishes that its dispersion is a complete commercial paint. Binder, application and final-film requirements still belong to the actual product being developed.

Equal active addition does not mean equal supplied mass

In the July model, the MFC material is described as a 10% suspension in water, while the modified-polyurea material is a 45% solution in dimethyl sulfoxide. The formula uses 30.0 g of the former and 6.7 g of the latter. Those additions supply 3.0 g and approximately 3.015 g of active material respectively, or approximately 0.5% of the 600 g batch.

That calculation explains the stated active comparison; it does not make the products identical. The supplied masses and carrier contributions differ. The disclosed formula also adjusts the added water. Replacing 30 g with 6.7 g in an unrelated formulation without accounting for the rest of the mixture would not reproduce this experiment.

When requesting samples, ask whether an addition level refers to supplied product, active additive, pigment mass or total formulation mass. Keep the denominator beside the number. If the active fraction is uncertain, record that uncertainty instead of rounding a nominal percentage into an exact equivalence. An equal-active starting point is one experimental choice, not a guarantee of equal structure, equal cost in use or equal application performance.

Keep yield stress and storage modulus distinct

Yield stress describes a stress criterion associated with the onset of flow or structural breakdown under a specified method. Storage modulus, G′, describes the elastic part of an oscillatory response. Both can be expressed in pascals, but they are different quantities. A graph showing both does not permit reading a value against whichever axis gives the preferred conclusion.

In the separate July model, the reported yield-stress values are 0.43 Pa for the reference, 2.90 Pa for MFC and 0.66 Pa for modified polyurea. These are supplier observations in that disclosed model, not MOS measurements, a universal ranking or a transferable acceptance specification.

The October article plots these properties against MFC concentration. The appropriate reading retains each legend and axis. Do not convert a visual trend into a universal minimum yield stress for storage stability, or replace an actual storage observation with a high G′ value. The public example does not provide such a universal acceptance limit.

For a laboratory comparison, define the measurement sequence before testing. Record temperature, geometry, sample conditioning, relevant shear history and the criterion used to report the result. If oscillatory data are used, retain the measurement conditions needed to interpret that response. The same units or the same instrument name are not sufficient evidence that results from different procedures are comparable.

Read the ageing photographs as finite observations

The October storage photographs compare the reference with the 0.5% active MFC dispersion at 24 hours, 7 days and 28 days. They do not document ageing photographs for every concentration in the rheology series. The source reports less instability for that MFC dispersion than for its reference at the illustrated observation times. It also states that both deteriorate over time. Describing the additive-containing sample simply as permanently stable would remove an important qualification from the source.

A photograph can show visible separation or material on a sampling tool. It cannot by itself establish the ease of redispersion throughout the container, the behaviour after transport or the properties of an applied film. Keep the image time, specimen identity and observation method together. Do not extrapolate a 28-day observation into an unstated commercial shelf life.

A useful test record distinguishes the presence of sediment, the character of that sediment, liquid separation and the effort needed for redispersion. These observations answer different practical questions. Avoid changing the sampling or stirring procedure halfway through a comparison: apparent improvement may then reflect the observation method rather than the formulation.

Design the next comparison around the actual coating

Use the public studies to frame a question, then test it in an identified reference coating. If the problem is hard settling during storage, define that failure before choosing the highest fresh viscosity. If the problem is poor levelling after application, a storage improvement alone is not an adequate decision criterion.

Proposed actual-coating trial record: conditions and limits of the decision
Decision stageRecord in the proposed trialKeep outside the conclusion until verified
FormulationBinder, pigment grade/loading, liquid balance and additive basisEquivalence to a different supplier model
PreparationAddition order, dispersion conditions, batch size and sample identityA transferable process from equipment speed alone
Fresh and aged comparisonDefined rheology method, storage conditions, observation times and reference samplesShelf life beyond the observed interval
ApplicationRelevant flow, appearance and film checks for the intended coatingUniversal superiority from a single settling result

This table is a proposed engineering record, not a test method certified by MOS. Where a candidate needs its own incorporation procedure, distinguish a controlled screening comparison from a separately labelled process-development trial. Otherwise a change in additive and a change in preparation become inseparable.

Ask a narrower question before purchasing a production quantity

The useful supplier conversation is not “which additive has the biggest number?” Ask which evidence concerns your binder, pigment package and application, what sample can be identified with the current technical document, and which result would justify moving beyond a laboratory trial. Request clarification of missing test conditions rather than filling them with assumptions from another brochure.

The existing dispersing-agent guide addresses wetting, dispersion and compatibility. The polyamide-wax guide addresses grade-specific incorporation and process history. Neither makes the two MFC studies interchangeable. Use the technical knowledge section for related formulation questions; this article does not offer a particular MFC or polyurea grade.

Sources: Borregaard, MFC and modified polyurea in a disclosed model dispersion, 23 July 2019; yield stress and settling observations in a separate dispersion, 29 October 2019. Supplier observations remain source-specific; calculations and proposed trial decisions are identified above.